Credit karma vs free credit report
Credit Karma Review: A Legit Free Credit Score or Scam?
Full Disclosure: We may be compensated when you click on links to credit card products from our advertising partners, such as American Express, Chase, Citi & Barclays. Opinions on this site are ours alone, and have not been reviewed or approved by the issuer. See our Advertiser Disclosure for more details. Thanks!
In this review, we will examine the different features of their site while answering the most common questions about its services.
By the time you reach the end, you will have a clear idea of whether joining this online service can help you manage your personal finances.
Table of contents
Table of Contents
Why Should I Check My Credit Score?
So, what’s the big deal with checking your credit score anyway? Is it really necessary? The answer is yes.
Your credit score is created based on the information in your credit report. Unfortunately, it’s not uncommon for credit reports to contain errors – sometimes major errors – resulting in low credit scores.
Sometimes this is due to clerical errors, but identity theft can often be the cause.
Regardless of the reason, if your credit report contains inaccuracies, it’s imperative that you deal with them quickly. Ignoring them won’t make them go away!
If you do get approved for a loan or credit card with poor credit, it is likely to be at a high interest rate, meaning you will pay tons of interest. This isn’t always the case though, you can read more here about credit cards for bad credit.
CreditKarma.com is one site that makes that possible.
How Does Credit Karma Work?
The site offers a wide variety of features and tools to its members. Let’s take a look at each one to see how they can help you stay on top of your credit situation.
1. Credit Card Reviews and Offers
As a member, you will receive matches to the best credit card offers based on your profile. You can add your own reviews, compare credit card terms, or apply for a credit card. You can even search the site for business credit cards.
2. Personal Loan Offers
Whatever the reason, applying for personal loans can be overwhelming, and it can be hard to know where to start.
CreditKarma.com aims to simplify the process by giving you a list of personal loans to consider based on your credit score. You’ll see a snapshot of each option, including the estimated loan amount, APR, and terms based on your input.
Also, when you take advantage of personal loan services, you can peruse unbiased reviews by members who have already worked with these lenders.
Hot Tip: Loans are affected by your credit score, so it’s helpful to work toward raising your score! You can try applying for some basic cards like the Blue Cash Everyday® Card from American Express, or the Chase Freedom Unlimited® Card to start building it now.
3. Automobile Loan Offers
Buying a car or refinancing an existing car loan is a major financial decision. Your credit score plays a big role in whether you will qualify, which lenders will work with you, and how big a down payment you’ll need.
Just like with personal loans, they will match you with offers you have a better chance of qualifying for. Then you can read reviews by members who have loans with those lenders.
4. Community Advice
When you post a question on the forum, it can be answered by anyone in the community, which includes average consumers as well as respected financial professionals.
Chances are, your question was previously addressed, and you can locate it by entering keywords in the search box.
Members of the community are encouraged to provide a thumbs up or thumbs down to questions and answers. The site keeps track of how many people were helped by each question too.
5. Credit Card Articles
Under the Resources tab, you will find articles written by financial professionals as well as “Your Weekly Money Scoop,” a roundup of articles from sites such as the New York Times, Forbes, and Huffington Post.
Hot Tip: At Upgraded Points, we also provide credit card reviews, articles on building credit, and other finance articles. However, we focus on keeping you traveling, including how to earn as many points as possible and redeem those points for maximum value!
6. Personal Finance Blog
The Credit Karma blog is divided into the following sections: Karma Culture, Company News, Industry News, Engineering, and Pressroom. It includes general posts about credit as well as information about the company.
An example article from the blog, which covers many different topics in the realm of personal finances. Image courtesy of CreditKarma.com.
7. Home and Auto Insurance Scores
Home and auto insurance scores estimate your risk based on factors such as:
Many states use these scores to predict how likely you are to file a claim and set premiums based on the result (although it is prohibited in some states).
Both scores are included with your free membership.
8. Free Credit Scores
In 2006, the 3 major credit reporting agencies (TransUnion, Equifax, and Experian) developed a joint algorithm to calculate a consumer’s VantageScore. Because each credit bureau calculates your VantageScore, you have 3 total.
You’ll get 2 VantageScores: one from TransUnion and the other from Equifax.
An increasing number of credit decisions are being made with the current version, Vantage 3.0. According to CreditKarma.com, Vantage 3.0 was used more than 8 billion times from July 2015 to June 2016.
Because the numbers are updated daily, you can check your credit score every day on their site. It’s a great way to track your score, so you’ll know right away if it goes up or down and whether you may need help with your personal finances.
Other Types of Credit Scores: FICO Score
|Credit Rating||Score Range|
Most people are familiar with FICO scores (from the Fair Isaac Corp.). FICO scores are the industry standard that lenders used to approve and deny new credit applications, make prescreened offers, and manage existing accounts. However, VantageScore credit scores are becoming more common.
FICO scores are based on 5 factors:
Each credit reporting agency calculates a FICO score, just like with VantageScores.
Other Types of Credit Scores: TransRisk Score
You may have heard the term “fako score.” It refers to any score that is not a FICO score. One example is a TransRisk score.
TransRisk scores are based solely on data in TransUnion credit reports. Like FICO scores, the range is 300-850. But FICO and TransRisk scores can vary by as many as 125 points.
Lenders do not use TransRisk scores anywhere near as often as FICO and VantageScores.
9. Credit Report
Check your credit reports for free each week to identify discrepancies and fix them as soon as possible.
Just a quick note: you may find that your free credit reports don’t always match. This can happen because you pulled them at different times, or a certain lender didn’t report to both bureaus; sometimes it may just be an error.
Can You Get a Full Credit Report?
When you apply for a loan, the lender pulls a full credit report, including your accounts, credit inquiries, public records, and collection activity. The lender also does a credit profile check to determine the types of credit you have, how long your accounts have been open, and whether you pay your bills on time.
As we already mentioned, TransUnion, Equifax and Experian are the 3 consumer credit reporting bureaus. With the free membership, you receive a full TransUnion credit report and a full Equifax credit report, both updated each week.
You can find the credit reporting agency phone numbers in the FAQ section below.
10. Credit Tools
Credit Score Simulator
For instance, what if you:
Discover what happens to your credit score when you take these or other actions by choosing from options provided by the simulator.
There are 4 calculators to help you learn about loans.
|Calculate||Information to Enter||Results|
|Home Affordability||Maximum house price you can afford and monthly payment|
||Monthly payment to repay loan in a specific time frame, or how long it will take to repay debt|
||Estimated monthly payment|
||Breakdown of each payment into interest and principal|
How to Sign up to Credit Karma
Joining is simple:
- Create an account including you email and password.
- Enter the last 4 numbers of your security number (required to access your credit bureau information).
- Verify your identity by answering questions.
Then you will have access to free credit scores and reports from your dashboard.
From your dashboard, you can connect online financial accounts to track your spending and figure out where your money is really going. You can also set email alerts to remind you when bills are due.
Is Credit Karma a Scam?
The top concern addressed in reviews is whether the site is legit or a scam.
CreditKarma.com makes money through its advertising partners.
You know those personalized credit card offers and loan recommendations we mentioned earlier? When you sign up for them (and you are under no obligation to do so), they earn money from these advertisers.
How Safe Is It?
Many people also wonder how safe it really is. After all, is it actually possible to get a totally free credit report online and be safe at the same time?
The best way to answer is to tell you about all the safeguards they have in place to protect you and your information.
Second, the site has a DigiCert EV SSL certificate, which means the site has the highest level of authentication.
Third, they use 128-bit encryption to protect the information you type in and doesn’t store your Social Security Number (remember, they only ask for the last 4 digits).
Fourth, nothing on the site can be altered because it is read-only.
What About the FTC Settlement?
You may have heard Credit Karma reached a settlement in 2014 with the Federal Trade Commission over allegations they misrepresented the security of their mobile app and failed to keep customer information private.
Apparently, they disabled SSL certificate validation, putting customers’ private info at risk. As a result, they have to submit to independent security assessments every other year through 2034.
Of course, it’s always important to safeguard your private information, especially when it comes to phishing scams. Don’t click on unsolicited links and attachments and never give your credit card information.
Personal Finance Tools and Your Points Strategy
Who doesn’t want to earn as many points as possible in order to enjoy travel (and non-travel) rewards? At UpgradedPoints.com, we proudly give you the tools, strategies, and information to collect points successfully.
So how does a personal finance website fit into this?
Well, every person’s credit situation is different. The more information you have about your individual situation, the better you can manage your financial life.
Hot Tip: Check out our Express Guide for earning points to help you quickly get started on your journey while safely beginning to build your credit!
When you use their services in conjunction with UpgradedPoints.com, you’ll be able to make informed decisions, since you’ll already know the potential impact they will have on your credit.
Is Credit Karma really free?
To check your credit score for free, visit www.creditkarma.com.
What are the credit reporting agency phone numbers?
Who owns CreditKarma.com?
The website is an independently owned and operated business with headquarters in San Francisco, CA.
Can I trust Credit Karma?
They only request the last 4 digits of your Social Security Number, no credit card payment information.
They also have safeguards in place to protect your private information such as 24/7 monitoring and firewalls. In addition, the site has a DigiCert EV SSL Certificate and used 128-bit encryption.
What is the customer service phone number?
They do not provide a phone number. The best way to reach customer service number is by email through the Help Center.
How can I check my credit score for free?
Visit the website at www.creditkarma.com to enroll and receive your free credit score. You’ll actually receive 2 scores, one from TransUnion and one from Equifax.
What are the 3 major credit bureaus? Which credit reporting agency is best?
The 3 major credit bureaus are TransUnion, Equifax, and Experian.
Is my Credit Karma credit score accurate?
Regarding the accuracy of your credit score, members, receive 2 legitimate Vantage Scores: one from TransUnion and the other from Equifax.
Your VantageScores may be slightly different than your FICO scores, which were once the industry standard. However, according to the site, Vantage scores were used more than 8 billion times from July 2015 to June 2016.
Where does Credit Karma get your credit score from?
They get your VantageScores from TransUnion and Equifax, 2 of the 3 major credit bureaus.
Does using free online tools affect your credit score?
How does Credit Karma make money?
They receive a referral fee when members apply for credit cards and personal loans that are suggested to them.
How does the Better Business Bureau rate Credit Karma?
Their BBB rating is “B.”
How do I download the Credit Karma app?
Download the app at iTunes or Google Play.
What is the best credit score site that doesn’t charge a fee?
Can I get a free credit score from Mint?
Recently, Mint.com began offering paid premium features too.
Your feedback has been sent. Thank you!
We take your comments very seriously as they really help us to improve the site.
If you’d like to share this piece with others, we’d be very grateful 🙂
An error occurred please try again later
About Jennifer Koebele
The Platinum Card® from American Express
Want The Best Lounge Access?
Get into more than 1,200+ airport lounges across 130 countries including the amazing Centurion® lounges.
We leverage $1,500+ in value each year with The Platinum Card®.
- Credit Karma’s score they show you has never been even close to what I get when I get the report from the source, TU, Experian, Equifax. You are receiving incorrect information each time they send you an update. So, as you are stating, Credit Karma does NOT make it possible.
2. They provide reports ONCE a month, not weekly.
3. Credit Karma has all those credit card and loan opportunities because that is where they make their money.
4. Even if you delete your account, they keep ALL your information; SS#, address, rating info, telephone, etc.
Big mistake joining Credit Karma!
Stay away from CreditKarma! They are always way off! 20+ points lower then I really was! They just want to make $ buy selling loans. Get your free credit report annually from the big 3 but do 1 every 4 months so you have a reliable FICO throughout the year!
This is not a FICO score it’s not as accurate and it was actually off by 20 points (lower then my actual!) which made me wait to bring up my credit score! In the meantime the interest rate went up .525% because credit karma was off by 22 points! It’s not as good as it seems and it takes forever to dispute something. I would get your free annual credit report from Trans Union and then four months later get Equifax and four months later get Experian. This way you get a free credit report throughout the year from each reliable FICO credit score companies. Credit Karma is not that good and it ruined my chance at a great mortgage rate! I think they’re great place to look for credit cards and loans. Not mortgages or refinancing just personal loans and credit cards.
SCAM. Here’s why: they will REDUCE the score they give you (which is not the FICO score which everyone figured out early on) by at least 10-20 points even if the only charge you have on your credit card is .5 percent (yes – one half of one percent) of the credit limit and even when you pay what you charged on your credit card within three business days of having made the charge. I ran an experiment by charging .4 percent on my zero balance/average limit Visa card and paid it off in three days of the charge so not only not “late” but so far ahead of their game that it should not have shown up at all. On my other card I carry a small credit balance all the time as I don’t often use the card but I want to get monthly paper statements to review and scan (and I never ever EVER do any financial banking online – ever) and this is a good way to keep the paper statements coming. Great for proof if you ever need it and credit card companies are so scandal ridden that it is good to have solid proof of what happens on your account directly from that company. So – my little “experiment” elicited a “WHAT HAPPENED” email from Credit Karma and a reduction of 19 points in the score they assigned me. AND they still showed the so-called “debt” a month after it had been paid. SCAM SCAM SCAM. Moreover your emails will be answered by poorly designed ‘bots – not by a real person. Definitely user beware! I deeply regret ever giving my personal information to Credit Karma and feel strongly they should be shut down. I hope their “business” fails spectacularly.
Credit Karma is a scam. They are getting their money from kick backs off of credit cards that charge high percentage APRs. The reason Credit Karma continues to tell people they have low scores. I have done all of the things that people are told to do to raise your score. I have ordered new credit, used it then paid off quickly, oh, too quickly? Okay, then run up credit and paid it back over long term paying out of course the interests on these cards. But as I pay these off my scores keep pummeling 40 points and when I click “what changed” it shows a $1200 decrease in overall payments or percentage of credit used, but a new card showed up with a balance on it of 200. Really? If the Big 3 or even Credit Karma has more than a non interested neutral scoring formula or algorithm, it should be consistent, but it doesn’t because that’s not the point. Then you have to actually write them and send your request to end the relationship and get off of credit karma. By the way, let me add my payment history is 100%. As far as I’m concerned, that is the only thing the big 3 ever should be concerned with, otherwise it shows an industry that has created very long arms of jurisdiction over people, and that means they have become useless in the real world. They need to go. There is no reason to set a premise for predatory credit cards other than to scam people. In the old days, you started out like everyone with a low interest card, then only if you deserved it, the interest charges went up- now its the other way around. Get rid of your high interest cards, get rid of credit karma.
Credit Karma is indeed nothing but a scam. You are not being provided with FICO scores, but merely Vantage scores which vary by wide standards depending on the “formula” being used to determine your credit worthiness.
The key is that they use factors to place your credit profile into a higher-risk category that they then pair with commensurate interest rates of their so-called “partners.” They are hopeful that as subscribers, you will utilize their vantage scores being reported to you and select from one of their partner lenders who entice you with statements by Credit Karma as “Excellent Odds of Approval” or “Good Odds of Approval.” These claims may be true alright, because if you closely examine the interest rate profile, it will place you in the range of high-risk credit worthiness with rates ranging from 18% to 29.99%.
Credit Karma makes their money by how many subscribers they can steer to such lenders using such scenarios when in fact if you’ll check with your local bank or credit union, you’ll find that your actual credit profile is likely much higher than being reported to you by Credit Karma.
Credit Karma will also provide you all sorts of online financial tools to make you believe that they are there to help you. Nothing could be further from the truth and you should always go directly to the credit reporting agencies to determine your actual credit worthiness.
As for Ms. Jennifer Koebele, you can bet your bottom credit dollar that she is handsomely compensated for her apparent support of Credit Karma and how “good” it is for you to use their online source to manage your credit. Shame on you, Ms. Koebele. I went to Credit Karma and signed on to determine the facts and it should interest readers to know that I had access to my actual FICO scores, even my auto FICO which is difficult at the very least to obtain. I was also provided with a credit worthiness profile. I matched this information against Credit Karma and in the case of Equifax, my score was more than 55 points different using the formula Credit Karma posts that is being utilized to make their determination.
If you want an honest assessment of your credit profile, never seek an online company claiming to want to help you. They are online to make money and lots of it. They do so in this instance by depressing your score profile, increasing your risk assessment and then attempt to pair you with their “Partner” credit cards or personal loans that will, excuse the phrase, screw the living hell out of you with interest rates far above what your actual credit is likely to support.
Do your research thoroughly and indeed, if you have actual credit problems work with your respective lenders and the credit reporting agencies, TransUnion, Experian or Equifax to negotiate a plan to resolve the credit problem and entry. Do not ever attempt to use credit repair companies, who cannot actually help you “erase bad credit” or fix anything. The only method they employ is to seek out very old and dated credit entries that have been sold several times over to third party collection agencies. The law requires that these collection agencies must have the original debt agreement with your signature in order to pursue the matter. Otherwise, they can do nothing but attempt to threaten you. Under the law, third party collection agencies may not report you to the credit reporting agencies as well, nor file judgements. In fact, there is little of nothing that these companies can do but hope to bluff you into paying something or all debt owed on delinquent accounts. You are allowed under the law to write a cease and desist letter that subsequently limits them to contact through the U.S. postal system. It’s well-advised to send such letters via certified mail, return receipt requested.
Finally, never hope for magic when it comes to your credit profile and scores. No company, Credit Karma included, is there more for you than they are for themselves. If you have credit problems, correct them through proper channels and do not be lured into obtaining credit that by law, can presently charge interest rates just below 30%, which may get you some small portion of cash or credit, but absolutely ruin your ability to ever catch up and become debt resilient. It can actually take nearly your lifetime to pay off this kind of credit or loan, so think carefully about a second job to help resolve the matter rather than more of a very bad decision to increase your debt load.
This is what Ms. Koebele should have been telling you but I suppose everything is for sale at a price as they say.
Hi John, we’d like to inform you that Jennifer in no way, shape, or form received compensation from Credit Karma for this article, nor was it commissioned by Credit Karma for our site. Just wanted to clear the air on that — we thank you for your honest feedback.